Next, I have
recorded some of the recent comments and factors
affecting central bank gold activity. As you can
see, the Germans and French have been making very
strong and positive statements about the role of
gold as a reserve asset. Recently the Portuguese
stated that they had considered selling gold but
rejected the concept due to an outcry of public
protest.
Recent
Comments on Central Bank Gold Activity

|
- German
Finance Minister, Theo Waigel
"Germany will
not sell one ounce of gold."Jean Pierre
Patat, French Central Bank
"Several central
banks which had sold gold from
their reserves now feel there is
no longer an advantage to selling
more bullion as any advantage was
outweighed by the loss on
remaining reserves from reducing
the gold price."
"It seems the market
is more influenced by
psychological phenomena than
central bank gold sales."
"Concern that European
central banks will sell large
portions of their gold reserves
are 'devoid of substance'".
Japanese
Prime Minister, Hashimoto
"Exchange rate
instability might encourage Japan
to sell some of its US Treasury
securities holdings and buy
gold."
- Shunjiro
Karasawa, Member of Japan's Lower
House of Parliament
- "Japan's
gold holdings are far too low
compared with other major
countries."
- Masaaki
Nakayama, Member of ruling
Democratic Party
"Excessive
dependence on the U.S. dollar and
sharply smaller gold reserves are
my growing concern."
-
- Alan
Greenspan, Chairman, Federal
Reserve
"The
extraordinary decline of the
price of gold is in small part
the result of central bank
sales."
-
- German
Polls show that:
Germans believe that
property or precious metaIs will
represent better investments than
cash savings following EMU.
-
- Swiss
polls show that:
A referendum to
reduce gold reserves would be
defeated.
-
|
 |
Other
factors which could have an important effect on
gold are the future of the EMU and a decline in
the U.S. stock market.
Effects
of the EMU on Gold

|
- 1. Widely
accepted that the Euro will be a
soft currency.
- Unlikely that European
central banks will want to
soften it further by
selling gold.
- Bundesbank wants a stronger
Euro.2. German people will
not accept a weak Euro. It can be
strengthened with greater gold
reserves.
3. Investment
firms can arrange the purchase of
any gold Europeans may want to
sell in an orderly manner. i.e.
Purchase a call option on any
gold central banks want to
mobilize.
4. Asian central banks
will have fewer alternatives for
investment of their $600 billion
of reserves.
|
 |
Even if the
EMU happens, it is generally accepted that the
Euro will be a soft currency. It is therefore
unlikely that the Bundesbank will allow it to be
even weaker by selling gold. Actually, we might
be surprised to see an overweighting of gold as
the least onerous method of strengthening the
Euro. The EMU appears to be an unpleasant brew,
concocted by the Eurocrats and administered to a,
so far, inattentive public. The French want a
shorter work week and a higher minimum wage. The
Italians refuse to reform their pension system
where a large percentage of the country is
considered disabled and eligible for a pension.
Finally, when and if EMU
happens, there will be few alternatives for Asian
central banks to invest their reserves. Gold will
have to be considered for a more prominent role.
Effects
on Gold of a U.S. Market Decline

|
- 1. A U.S.
market decline, this time, would
likely affect U.S. consumption.
Also, the dollar would decline as
foreigners sold shares and bonds.
2. Without the U.S. as
the consumption junkie for the
world, European and Japanese
economies would weaken further.
3. EMU would
come under pressure as more
expansive policies would be
desperately needed in Europe.
4. Serious disruptions
in European debt and currency
markets would occur.
5. With the Swiss
trying to debase their currency,
there would be few alternatives
to gold.
6. Gold,
already in deficit with producers
and speculators short, could rise
dramatically.
7. Gold shares already
at bear market bottom prices
should rise substantially. Also,
as money flowed into more
defensive investments i.e. gold
shares, the funds flow would
dwarf the small market
capitalization of all gold
shares.
|
 |
We are faced
with the simple fact that, as the stock market
and dollar continue to be strong, gold is
rejected as an investment vehicle. As the
following charts show, gold has the most negative
correlation to the stock market of any asset and
is now at an all-time extreme undervaluation
relative to the Dow.


When the stock market
declines it will weaken consumer demand which
will have a significant impact on fragile
European and Japanese economies. As the economy
softens in the U.S. the Fed will no doubt lower
interest rates which will result in a declining
dollar, but even more important, we will probably
opt for a weaker dollar to strengthen exports at
the same time as other countries want weaker
currencies to stimulate their exports.
Competitive currency devaluations should begin a
major bull market in gold. The basic
supply/demand deficit will then come into play
resulting in even greater strength in gold. There
is also a strong relationship between dollar
strength and gold's weakness.
Based on gold's gross
undervaluation relative to the Dow, gold's price
being far below its 26 year mean and all the
factors previously mentioned, at the very least
there is a solid case that the current 12 year
low in gold, or 20 year low adjusted for
inflation, makes a very good entry point.
Turning to gold shares we
are looking at the lowest valuations since the
bottom in 1992. The reason to own shares relative
to bullion is that they offer much more leverage.
Typically the shares have three times the
percentage move that bullion has. Actually, the
juniors and high cost producers tend to do much
better than that.
Market
Capitalization of Gold Shares is Small

|
- 1. Estimates of
worldwide gold share total market
value is under $50 billion.
2. Estimates of
available "float" are
below $30 billion.
3. Even
assuming a 20% increase in shares
as a result of financing in a
strong gold environment, any
serious interest in gold shares
would dwarf the available supply.
|
 |
The
exploration shares have been decimated by Bre-X.
In case you were on the moon and missed it, this
was a $4 billion scam run by a bunch of clowns in
the jungle of Indonesia. The only reaI value in
this company may be the movie rights.
We met these fellows early
in the game and based on some geologists we had
confidence in we bought some stock at $3. We felt
they had found a few million ounces and the stock
could be worth $10. Before we knew it they were
talking about 20 million ounces and the stock was
$40. We got out. It went straight to $300 as
projections reached 100 million ounces with
dozens of analysts endorsing these numbers.
The head geologist who, in
addition to having four wives and a degree in
salting, either jumped or was found pushed out of
a helicopter on the way to explain to Freeport,
Bre-X's new partner, why the new holes drilled by
Freeport found no gold. Actually, the geologist's
body was "hard to identify" and there
are people who claim to have seen him in various
parts of Asia.
At any rate, the $4 billion
drained out of the market overnight resulted in
some nasty margin calls and the
liquidation of the exploration stocks became a
waterfall.
This has created incredible
values with declines of 75% not uncommon. This
was a once in a lifetime scam and a once in a
lifetime washout.
As you know, the market is
like a ferris wheel, sometimes you are in the car
on top and sometimes that car is on the bottom.
This time the gold stock car is off the tracks.
TVX sells at the price it traded at before it
bought and expanded a deposit in Greece which
will mine gold at $125 per ounce, generating a
cash flow of over $120 million per year starting
in three years which is three times the company's
current cash flow. Golden Star, an exploration
company, has declined over 60% from its 1997
high. It is back to the same price as four or
five years ago. In 1992 they had 7 gold projects
in various stages of development and no diamond
projects. Today they have 36 gold projects and 31
diamond projects.
There are only two reasons
to buy gold shares. Either you think the price of
bullion is going to rise or you can identify a
company which has the potential to expand its
reserves at a rate not recognized in the
marketplace.
With a worldwide gold share
market of about $50 billion, about 1/3 of Intel,
and a float well below that, these shares must be
purchased before gold begins to rise. That is why
the shares rose 30% before gold took off in 1993.
Today, gold shares have the lowest relative
strength in over 20 years. Also, today you have a
clear acquisition emphasis by the major gold
companies. Each is on the acquisition trail and
when gold starts to move we believe that a
corporate takeover binge will unfold. This will
reduce this tiny sector even further.
Even if you do not accept
the concept that gold is going to enter a secular
bull market, you can look at an investment in
gold shares on a cyclical basis. Since 1980 the
Gold Stock Index (XAU) has made six attempts to
break through 150. A move to 150 would be a 50%
gain or perhaps twice that in the more aggressive
gold equities. This is the first time that the
potential launching base has been this high.
Should an upside break of 150 occur, there would
probably be a dramatic rise in the gold shares.
What we can conclude is
that the structure of the gold market is
explosive. Not only is there a large and
expanding deficit but there is a huge effective
short position as well. We have outright
speculator shorts, producers which have sold
future production aggressively and central banks
which have sold calls to earn income.
With Asian central banks
grossly underinvested in gold and investment
demand in general nonexistent, it is likely that
any surprise would be purchases by Asian central
banks and investors adding more fuel to the fire
once the advance starts.
We can also conclude that
the relationship of gold to paper markets is at
the greatest extreme in history and gold shares
are at valuations seen only at the 1992 low
before the major advance. Clearly, both gold and
gold bullion are offering extremely attractive
entry points.
The trap has been set. With
thousands of tonnes sold short by short sellers
and producers into an expanding deficit, the
short sellers must not only continue to sell
short at their current high rate to hold gold
down but must steadily increase their short sales
to fill the steady expansion of the deficit. The
problem arises when the shorts try to cover. The
only source of supply would be huge sales by
central banks to bail out the shorts.
In the event of a market
squeeze, central banks, the ultimate trend
followers, would most likely not only not sell,
but they would become fearful of losing the gold
they had out on loan to short sellers and would
call the gold back, which they can do on short
notice. That of course would magnify the problem
and the worse it got, with a highly inverted
lease rate, the more gold would be demanded back
by the central banks. As we have mentioned
previously, much of the borrowed gold has been
fabricated into jewelry so it would be difficult
if not impossible to return a significant percent
of the gold loaned out by the central banks.
When gold turns up, gold
shares, from their current depressed base and
with their inherent leverage to the gold price,
will be the place to be. Higher cost mining
companies and the washed out exploration sector
will have the biggest returns. In the past, when
the gold share advance began, high cost South
African mining companies gained as much as 40% in
the first week of the rally.
I've now given you the
complete and I think compelling case for gold and
gold shares. There is just one more piece of
evidence to complete the picture. How many people
here think that gold will be over $500 in a year?
How many people think that gold will be over $400
in a year? I rest my case.
|